Divorce and Stridhan: What Every Indian Woman Must Know About Her Rights
- Legal Associate
- 3 hours ago
- 10 min read
Introduction
In Indian matrimonial disputes, one of the most overlooked yet vital legal issues is that of Stridhan. While the conversation around alimony, child custody, and maintenance has gained prominence, the legal rights of a woman over her Stridhan often remain underexplored and poorly understood. This blog post aims to provide a comprehensive legal guide for Indian women—both residents and NRIs on the concept of Stridhan, its legal protection under Indian law, and the remedies available in the event of matrimonial breakdown. The objective is not only to educate but to empower women to assert their rightful claims and encourage fair, lawful resolution of marital property disputes.
The importance of this topic has increased over the years with the steady rise in matrimonial litigations, and it is crucial that every woman in India.
Understanding Stridhan: Definition and Meaning
The term Stridhan has its origin in ancient Hindu law and literally means "woman's property." However, the modern interpretation under statutory laws and judicial decisions has significantly broadened its scope. Stridhan includes all movable and immovable property voluntarily given to a woman before, during, or after her marriage.
It is important to note that Stridhan is distinct from dowry. While dowry refers to demands made by the groom's family, often under coercion, Stridhan consists of gifts voluntarily given to the woman by her parents, relatives, or friends and is legally her exclusive property.
What Constitutes Stridhan
The following items are legally recognized as part of a woman’s Stridhan:
Gifts received before the marriage, including those given by parents, siblings, relatives, or friends.
Gifts received at the time of marriage, including those presented at ceremonies and social functions.
Gifts received during the course of the marriage, such as on birthdays, anniversaries, religious occasions, and during childbirth.
Property—movable and immovable—that is purchased by the woman from her own earnings or received through inheritance.
Jewelry, clothing, household items, cash, bonds, fixed deposits, and valuable possessions received during her life stages related to marriage.
What Does Not Constitute Stridhan
There are several misconceptions regarding Stridhan. Items that do not fall under the ambit of Stridhan include:
Dowry items that are demanded unlawfully by the groom’s family.
Gifts given jointly to the couple which are not specifically earmarked for the woman.
Assets acquired by the husband alone, or property registered in his name without any proven contribution from the woman.
Items that the woman cannot prove were given voluntarily and exclusively to her.
Therefore, the distinction between voluntarily given gifts and coerced dowry or jointly acquired property is critical in defining what can be claimed as Stridhan.
Legal Framework Governing Stridhan in India
Indian law provides a robust legal framework for the protection of a woman's right over her Stridhan. Various statutory provisions, judicial precedents, and procedural safeguards are in place to ensure that women are not deprived of their lawful property under the guise of marriage or marital breakdown.
Under Section 14(1), any property possessed by a female Hindu, whether acquired before or after the commencement of the Act, is held by her as her absolute property. This includes Stridhan and has been reaffirmed in various Supreme Court rulings. This provision ensures that a woman's right over her property, including Stridhan, is not restricted or contingent on the goodwill of her husband or in-laws.
This section empowers the court to make appropriate orders regarding any property that may have been presented at or about the time of marriage which may belong jointly to both husband and wife. While Stridhan, being the woman’s absolute property, does not fall under joint property, this section is relevant when property is presented in both names but the woman’s claim is dominant.
This Act provides specific provisions for the protection of women’s rights to reside in a shared household and to claim monetary relief including the return of Stridhan. Section 19 allows courts to pass protection orders, while Section 20 allows monetary compensation for loss or damage to Stridhan.
4. IPC – Section 406 / BNS - Section 316
Section 406 IPC now amended Section 316 of BNS relates to criminal breach of trust. If a woman’s Stridhan is withheld unlawfully by her husband or in-laws, they may be prosecuted under this section. The refusal to return Stridhan despite demand constitutes a criminal offence.
5. IPC– Section 498A / BNS - Section 85
This section criminalizes cruelty by the husband or his relatives, including the refusal to return Stridhan or harassment relating to it. Though often invoked alongside Section 406 of IPC/ Section 316 of BNS, this provision is specifically aimed at protecting women from all forms of cruelty during the marriage.
Stridhan and Dowry: Legal Distinction
Stridhan is often incorrectly equated with dowry. However, legally and conceptually, they are different.
Stridhan is given voluntarily and becomes the woman’s absolute property.
Dowry is any property or valuable security demanded by the groom or his family as a condition of the marriage.
Dowry is illegal under the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961, and invites penal action. In contrast, Stridhan is lawful and protected by various civil and criminal laws, as discussed above.
The courts have time and again reiterated that gifts voluntarily given at the time of marriage to the bride are Stridhan, whereas anything given as a demand or compulsion constitutes dowry and is punishable under law.
Landmark Case Laws on Stridhan Rights in Divorce Proceedings
To understand the legal treatment of Stridhan in India, we must look at authoritative judgments by the Supreme Court and various High Courts. These judicial pronouncements have shaped the interpretation and enforcement of Stridhan claims.
Pratibha Rani v. Suraj Kumar & Anr., (1985)
This is a seminal Supreme Court judgment that clarified the concept of Stridhan. The Court held:
"A Hindu married woman is the absolute owner of her Stridhan property and can dispose of it at her own will. Her husband has no control over it, and if he or his relatives misappropriate it or deny her possession, they can be held criminally liable under Section 406 IPC."
In this case, the wife’s Stridhan was retained by her in-laws. The Court not only upheld her ownership over the Stridhan but also ruled that its misappropriation amounts to criminal breach of trust.
Krishna Bhattacharjee v. Sarathi Choudhury, (2016) 2 SCC 705
In this recent judgment, the Supreme Court held that:
"A woman can claim her Stridhan even after judicial separation or divorce. The refusal to return Stridhan constitutes a continuing offence under Section 406 IPC."
The Court also held that limitation does not apply strictly to Stridhan recovery, as the offence continues till the property is returned.
Procedure for Claiming Stridhan During or After Divorce
Understanding the steps involved in claiming Stridhan is vital for effective legal remedy. Whether during ongoing divorce proceedings or post-separation, the woman must take timely action supported by legal documentation and evidence.
Step 1: Send a Legal Notice
The first step is often to send a formal legal notice demanding the return of Stridhan articles. This puts the husband and in-laws on notice and creates a record of the demand.
Step 2: File a Complaint under Section 406 IPC
If the property is not returned after the legal notice, the woman may file a criminal complaint for criminal breach of trust under Section 406 of the IPC. This can be done at the police station or directly before the Magistrate.
Step 3: Simultaneous Proceedings under Domestic Violence Act
A claim for return of Stridhan may also be incorporated under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. A Magistrate can pass orders for the return of specific movable assets and even attach or seize them if necessary.
Step 4: Include Stridhan Claim in Divorce Petition or Counterclaim
If the woman is a party in a divorce proceeding, she can include the Stridhan claim as part of her pleadings under Section 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act. The family court is empowered to pass suitable orders.
Step 5: Civil Suit for Recovery of Stridhan (Alternative)
Alternatively, or additionally, a separate civil suit can be filed for recovery of property and damages if there is clear documentation of the Stridhan and evidence of refusal to return.
Stridhan and NRI Marriages: Legal Complexities and Jurisdictional Challenges
In the context of NRI marriages, the issue of Stridhan becomes even more complex due to cross-border legal systems, difficulty in enforcement, and jurisdictional obstacles. Many Indian women who marry NRI husbands face difficulties in retrieving their Stridhan after matrimonial breakdown, especially if the husband resides abroad.
Common Challenges Faced by NRI Women
Abandonment and Stridhan Retention Abroad: Many NRI husbands take the woman and her belongings abroad, then desert her or throw her out of the home, keeping her jewellery, gifts, and other Stridhan in foreign territory.
Jurisdictional Limitations: If the Stridhan is kept in a foreign country, Indian courts may have limited ability to order its return, especially if there is no treaty or enforcement agreement in place with the concerned country.
Difficulty in Filing Police Complaints from Abroad: Women residing overseas or those who have returned to India after abandonment often face practical hurdles in lodging FIRs or pursuing cases, especially if they are unaware of their rights.
Foreign Divorce Decrees Ignoring Indian Law: Often NRI husbands get ex parte divorce decrees in foreign courts. These decrees may not consider the woman’s rights under Indian law, including her right to Stridhan.
Legal Remedies Available to NRI Women in India
Filing an FIR Under Section 406 IPC/ Section 316 BNS: The woman can initiate a complaint for criminal breach of trust even if the offence occurred partially or fully abroad, as long as part of the matrimonial life or transactions took place in India.
Approaching the Family Court in India: Under Section 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act, women can seek return of Stridhan in a divorce petition filed in India, even if the husband is residing abroad.
Action Under the Domestic Violence Act: Courts have recognized the applicability of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 even when the matrimonial relationship spans multiple countries, provided there is a connection with India.
Involving Indian Embassies and Women’s Cells: Indian embassies in many countries have a designated legal cell or helpline for Indian women in distress. These bodies can help with initiating legal actions, passport impounding, and coordination with local authorities.
Passport Seizure and Look-Out Circulars (LOCs): In severe cases where the husband fails to respond to legal summons or refuses to return the Stridhan, the woman may seek impounding of the NRI husband’s passport or request an LOC to prevent him from entering or leaving India freely.
Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties (MLATs): For certain countries, India has signed MLATs which allow sharing of legal documents and assistance in execution of court orders, including recovery of property.
Evidentiary Requirements and Documentation for Stridhan Claims
The success of any Stridhan claim whether civil or criminal depends on the strength of the evidence provided by the claimant. Courts rely heavily on proof that the items in question qualify as Stridhan and that the woman was denied access to them.
Important Evidence to Preserve
Photographs and Video Footage: Images of wedding ceremonies showing the giving of gifts, jewellery, or cash can be critical. Many courts accept wedding videos as valid evidence of gifting.
Gift Lists and Bills: Lists prepared at the time of marriage, including detailed itemisation of jewellery, electronics, and furniture, serve as crucial proof. Bills or invoices in the woman’s or her parents’ name strengthen the claim.
Witness Testimony: Testimonies of parents, friends, relatives, or even jewelers who prepared the ornaments can be submitted in court. Such depositions carry weight under the Indian Evidence Act.
Bank Transfers or Financial Transactions: Evidence of dowry amounts or funds transferred for purchase of gifts or Stridhan items from the woman’s family to the husband’s account or jointly held accounts can also support the case.
Correspondence and Messages: Any WhatsApp chats, emails, or messages where the woman asks for return of Stridhan or where the husband/in-laws acknowledge receipt of such items are valuable.
Police Complaints or FIRs: Early complaints made to the police, women’s cell, or helpline centers create a solid trail of evidence and demonstrate the woman’s consistent efforts to recover her Stridhan.
Stridhan vs. Dowry: Understanding the Legal Distinction
Although both Stridhan and dowry may involve gifts given at the time of marriage, Indian law draws a clear distinction between the two, especially in terms of ownership, legality, and recoverability.
What is Dowry?
Defined under Section 2 of the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961, dowry is:
“Any property or valuable security given or agreed to be given either directly or indirectly by one party to a marriage to the other party to the marriage or by the parents of either party or by any other person, at or before or any time after the marriage in connection with the marriage of the said parties.”
Dowry is illegal and punishable under Sections 3 and 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act.
What is Stridhan?
Stridhan, on the other hand, is:
The voluntary gift or property given to the bride without any demand or coercion.
It is legally the woman’s absolute property and she can dispose of it as she pleases.
It is recoverable, and its retention by husband or in-laws is a criminal offence under Section 406 IPC if they refuse to return it.
Key Distinctions
Criteria | Stridhan | Dowry |
Ownership | Woman | Not recognized as ownership |
Legality | Legal | Illegal |
Recoverability | Recoverable under law | Action lies under Dowry Act |
Criminal Liability | Yes, if not returned | Yes, if demanded or accepted |
Role of Criminal Courts vs. Family Courts
Many women are confused about which forum to approach for Stridhan recovery: should it be a police complaint, a criminal court, or a civil/family court?
Criminal Courts (for Section 406 IPC/ 316 BNS)
A complaint for criminal breach of trust for Stridhan can be filed in the local police station or Magistrate court.
If the complaint is registered under Section 406, the accused may face arrest, charge-sheet, and even imprisonment upon conviction.
Family Courts (for Section 27 HMA or Maintenance)
Section 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act permits recovery of Stridhan as part of a divorce petition or separate application in the family court.
Women can also seek maintenance, residence rights, and custody of children along with Stridhan recovery.
Preventive Legal Measures: Before and During Marriage
Women and their families can adopt some preventive legal measures to safeguard Stridhan and avoid future disputes.
Prepare a Gift List: List all items—jewellery, electronics, clothes, cash, etc.—clearly stating who gave them. Maintain copies.
Maintain Receipts and Valuation Reports: Keep invoices, appraisal certificates for ornaments, and bank transaction details.
Video Recording of Gifting Ceremony: Take a video of the gifting process to prove voluntary transfer.
Avoid Giving Dowry: Dowry is not only illegal but also morally and legally indefensible.
Prenuptial Agreements: While not very common in India, a mutual agreement signed before marriage about personal assets, maintenance, and property can serve as a future protection (not legally enforceable as a contract but may have evidentiary value).
Conclusion: Know Your Rights, Protect Your Dignity
Stridhan is more than just property it is a symbol of a woman’s independence, respect, and social identity. Under Indian law, Stridhan is a sacrosanct right and any denial of its return is a punishable offence.
Whether you are a resident Indian or an NRI woman:
Document everything related to your marriage and gifts.
If your Stridhan is withheld or misappropriated, act promptly.
File complaints under Section 406 IPC/ 316 of BNS or initiate legal proceedings under Section 27 HMA.
Use the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act to claim your right to reside and seek protection orders.
More Informative blog post:
Comments